Changeset 14471 for branches/MemPRAlgorithm/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring/3.3

Timestamp:

12/09/16 15:56:22 (8 years ago)

Author:

abeham

Message:

#2701:

• Updated GraphColoringProblem and Problems.Instances
  • Added new fitness function from literature
  • Added DIMACS benchmark instances
• Updated LinearLinkageEncoding
  • Added HammingSimilarityCalculator

Location:

branches/MemPRAlgorithm/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring/3.3

Files:

• GraphColoringProblem.cs (modified) (5 diffs)
• HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring-3.3.csproj (modified) (2 diffs)
• Plugin.cs.frame (modified) (2 diffs)

branches/MemPRAlgorithm/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring/3.3/GraphColoringProblem.cs

@@ -21 +21 @@
 
 using System;
+using System.Linq;
+using HeuristicLab.Analysis;
 using HeuristicLab.Common;
 using HeuristicLab.Core;
@@ -26 +28 @@
 using HeuristicLab.Encodings.LinearLinkageEncoding;
 using HeuristicLab.Optimization;
+using HeuristicLab.Optimization.Operators;
 using HeuristicLab.Parameters;
 using HeuristicLab.Persistence.Default.CompositeSerializers.Storable;
+using HeuristicLab.Problems.Instances;
 
 namespace HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring {
+  public enum FitnessFunction { Prioritized, Penalized }
   [Item("Graph Coloring Problem (GCP)", "Attempts to find a coloring using a minimal number of colors that doesn't produce a conflict.")]
+  [Creatable(CreatableAttribute.Categories.CombinatorialProblems, Priority = 135)]
   [StorableClass]
-  public sealed class GraphColoringProblem : SingleObjectiveBasicProblem<LinearLinkageEncoding> {
+  public sealed class GraphColoringProblem : SingleObjectiveBasicProblem<LinearLinkageEncoding>, IProblemInstanceConsumer<GCPData> {
 
     public override bool Maximization {
@@ -38 +44 @@
     }
 
-    private IValueParameter<BoolMatrix> adjacencyMatrixParameter;
-    public IValueParameter<BoolMatrix> AdjacencyMatrixParameter {
-      get { return adjacencyMatrixParameter; }
+    [Storable]
+    private IValueParameter<IntMatrix> adjacencyListParameter;
+    public IValueParameter<IntMatrix> AdjacencyListParameter {
+      get { return adjacencyListParameter; }
+    }
+    [Storable]
+    private IValueParameter<EnumValue<FitnessFunction>> fitnessFunctionParameter;
+    public IValueParameter<EnumValue<FitnessFunction>> FitnessFunctionParameter {
+      get { return fitnessFunctionParameter; }
     }
 
@@ -47 +59 @@
     private GraphColoringProblem(GraphColoringProblem original, Cloner cloner)
       : base(original, cloner) {
-      adjacencyMatrixParameter = cloner.Clone(original.adjacencyMatrixParameter);
+      adjacencyListParameter = cloner.Clone(original.adjacencyListParameter);
+      fitnessFunctionParameter = cloner.Clone(original.fitnessFunctionParameter);
+      RegisterEventHandlers();
     }
     public GraphColoringProblem() {
-      Encoding = new LinearLinkageEncoding("lle") { Length = 32 };
-      Parameters.Add(adjacencyMatrixParameter = new ValueParameter<BoolMatrix>("AdjacencyMatrix", "The matrix that describes whether two nodes are linked."));
-      
-      var rand = new System.Random(0);
-      var matrix = new BoolMatrix(32, 32);
-      for (var i = 0; i < 31; i++) {
-        for (var j = i + 1; j < 32; j++) {
-          matrix[i, j] = rand.NextDouble() < 0.2;
-          matrix[j, i] = matrix[i, j];
-        }
+      Encoding = new LinearLinkageEncoding("lle");
+      Parameters.Add(adjacencyListParameter = new ValueParameter<IntMatrix>("Adjacency List", "The adjacency list that describes the (symmetric) edges in the graph with nodes from 0 to N-1."));
+      Parameters.Add(fitnessFunctionParameter = new ValueParameter<EnumValue<FitnessFunction>>("Fitness Function", "The function to use for evaluating the quality of a solution.", new EnumValue<FitnessFunction>(FitnessFunction.Prioritized)));
+
+      var imat = new IntMatrix(defaultInstance.Length, 2);
+      for (var i = 0; i < defaultInstance.Length; i++) {
+        imat[i, 0] = defaultInstance[i].Item1 - 1;
+        imat[i, 1] = defaultInstance[i].Item2 - 1;
       }
-      AdjacencyMatrixParameter.Value = matrix;
+      Encoding.Length = defaultInstanceNodes;
+      AdjacencyListParameter.Value = imat;
+      BestKnownQuality = 7;
+
+      InitializeOperators();
+      RegisterEventHandlers();
     }
 
@@ -68 +85 @@
     }
 
+    protected override void OnEncodingChanged() {
+      base.OnEncodingChanged();
+
+      Parameterize();
+    }
+
+    [StorableHook(HookType.AfterDeserialization)]
+    private void AfterDeserialization() {
+      RegisterEventHandlers();
+    }
+
+    private void RegisterEventHandlers() {
+      fitnessFunctionParameter.ValueChanged += FitnessFunctionParameterOnValueChanged;
+      fitnessFunctionParameter.Value.ValueChanged += FitnessFunctionOnValueChanged;
+    }
+
+    private void FitnessFunctionParameterOnValueChanged(object sender, EventArgs eventArgs) {
+      fitnessFunctionParameter.Value.ValueChanged += FitnessFunctionOnValueChanged;
+      OnReset();
+    }
+
+    private void FitnessFunctionOnValueChanged(object sender, EventArgs eventArgs) {
+      BestKnownQualityParameter.Value = null;
+      OnReset();
+    }
+
     public override double Evaluate(Individual individual, IRandom random) {
-      var matrix = adjacencyMatrixParameter.Value;
-      var lle = individual.LinearLinkage("lle");
-      var groups = lle.GetGroups();
+      var fitFun = FitnessFunctionParameter.Value.Value;
+      var adjList = adjacencyListParameter.Value;
+      var lle = individual.LinearLinkage(Encoding.Name).ToLLEe(); // LLE-e encoding uses the highest indexed member as group number
+
+      switch (fitFun) {
+        case FitnessFunction.Prioritized: {
+            var conflicts = 0;
+            var colors = lle.Distinct().Count();
+            for (var r = 0; r < adjList.Rows; r++) {
+              if (lle[adjList[r, 0]] == lle[adjList[r, 1]]) conflicts++; // both nodes are adjacent and have the same color (are in the same group)
+            }
+            // number of conflicts is the integer part of the quality
+            // number of colors constitutes the fractional part
+            // the number of fractional digits is defined by the maximum number of possible colors (each node its own color)
+            var mag = Math.Pow(10, -(int)Math.Ceiling(Math.Log10(lle.Length)));
+            // the value is e.g. 4.03 for 4 conflicts with 3 colors (and less than 100 nodes)
+            return conflicts + colors * mag;
+          }
+        case FitnessFunction.Penalized: {
+            // Fitness function from
+            // David S. Johnson, Cecilia R. Aragon, Lyle A. McGeoch, and Catherine Schevon. 1991.
+            // Optimization by simulated annealing: An experimental evaluation; part II, graph coloring and number partitioning.
+            // Operations Research 39(3), pp. 378–406.
+            // All local optima of this function correspond to legal colorings.
+            var colors = lle.GroupBy(x => x).ToDictionary(x => x.Key, x => new EvaluationHelper() { ColorCount = x.Count() });
+            for (var r = 0; r < adjList.Rows; r++) {
+              var color1 = lle[adjList[r, 0]];
+              var color2 = lle[adjList[r, 1]];
+              if (color1 == color2) colors[color1].ConflictCount++;
+            }
+            return 2 * colors.Sum(x => x.Value.ColorCount * x.Value.ConflictCount) - colors.Sum(x => x.Value.ColorCount * x.Value.ColorCount);
+          }
+        default: throw new InvalidOperationException(string.Format("Unknown fitness function {0}.", fitFun));
+      }
+    }
+
+    private class EvaluationHelper {
+      public int ColorCount { get; set; }
+      public int ConflictCount { get; set; }
+    }
+
+    public override void Analyze(Individual[] individuals, double[] qualities, ResultCollection results, IRandom random) {
+      var orderedIndividuals = individuals.Zip(qualities, (i, q) => new { Individual = i, Quality = q }).OrderBy(z => z.Quality);
+      var best = Maximization ? orderedIndividuals.Last().Individual.LinearLinkage(Encoding.Name) : orderedIndividuals.First().Individual.LinearLinkage(Encoding.Name);
+
+      var adjList = AdjacencyListParameter.Value;
+      var lle = best.ToLLEe();
       var conflicts = 0;
-      var colors = 0;
-      foreach (var g in groups) {
-        colors++;
-        for (var i = 0; i < g.Count - 1; i++) {
-          for (var j = i + 1; j < g.Count; j++) {
-            if (matrix[g[i], g[j]]) conflicts++; // both nodes are adjacent and have the same color (are in the same group)
-          }
-        }
+      var colors = lle.Distinct().Count();
+      for (var r = 0; r < adjList.Rows; r++) {
+        if (lle[adjList[r, 0]] == lle[adjList[r, 1]]) conflicts++; // both nodes are adjacent and have the same color (are in the same group)
       }
 
-      var mag = Math.Pow(10, -(int)Math.Ceiling(Math.Log10(matrix.Rows)));
-      return conflicts + colors * mag;
-    }
+      IResult res;
+      if (!results.TryGetValue("Best Solution Colors", out res)) {
+        res = new Result("Best Solution Colors", new IntValue(colors));
+        results.Add(res);
+      } else ((IntValue)res.Value).Value = colors;
+      if (!results.TryGetValue("Best Solution Conflicts", out res)) {
+        res = new Result("Best Solution Conflicts", new IntValue(conflicts));
+        results.Add(res);
+      } else ((IntValue)res.Value).Value = conflicts;
+    }
+
+    public void Load(GCPData data) {
+      Encoding.Length = data.Nodes;
+      AdjacencyListParameter.Value = new IntMatrix(data.Adjacencies);
+      if (FitnessFunctionParameter.Value.Value == FitnessFunction.Prioritized && data.BestKnownColors.HasValue) {
+        var mag = Math.Pow(10, -(int)Math.Ceiling(Math.Log10(data.Nodes)));
+        // the value is e.g. 4.03 for 4 conflicts with 3 colors (and less than 100 nodes)
+        BestKnownQuality = data.BestKnownColors.Value * mag;
+      } else BestKnownQualityParameter.Value = null;
+      Name = data.Name;
+      Description = data.Description;
+      OnReset();
+    }
+
+    private void InitializeOperators() {
+      Operators.Add(new HammingSimilarityCalculator());
+      Operators.Add(new QualitySimilarityCalculator());
+      Operators.Add(new PopulationSimilarityAnalyzer(Operators.OfType<ISolutionSimilarityCalculator>()));
+
+      Parameterize();
+    }
+
+    private void Parameterize() {
+      foreach (var simCalc in Operators.OfType<ISolutionSimilarityCalculator>()) {
+        simCalc.SolutionVariableName = Encoding.Name;
+        simCalc.QualityVariableName = Evaluator.QualityParameter.ActualName;
+      }
+    }
+
+    #region Default Instance (myciel6.col)
+    private static readonly int defaultInstanceNodes = 95;
+    private static readonly Tuple<int, int>[] defaultInstance = {
+Tuple.Create(1, 2),
+Tuple.Create(1, 4),
+Tuple.Create(1, 7),
+Tuple.Create(1, 9),
+Tuple.Create(1, 13),
+Tuple.Create(1, 15),
+Tuple.Create(1, 18),
+Tuple.Create(1, 20),
+Tuple.Create(1, 25),
+Tuple.Create(1, 27),
+Tuple.Create(1, 30),
+Tuple.Create(1, 32),
+Tuple.Create(1, 36),
+Tuple.Create(1, 38),
+Tuple.Create(1, 41),
+Tuple.Create(1, 43),
+Tuple.Create(1, 49),
+Tuple.Create(1, 51),
+Tuple.Create(1, 54),
+Tuple.Create(1, 56),
+Tuple.Create(1, 60),
+Tuple.Create(1, 62),
+Tuple.Create(1, 65),
+Tuple.Create(1, 67),
+Tuple.Create(1, 72),
+Tuple.Create(1, 74),
+Tuple.Create(1, 77),
+Tuple.Create(1, 79),
+Tuple.Create(1, 83),
+Tuple.Create(1, 85),
+Tuple.Create(1, 88),
+Tuple.Create(1, 90),
+Tuple.Create(2, 3),
+Tuple.Create(2, 6),
+Tuple.Create(2, 8),
+Tuple.Create(2, 12),
+Tuple.Create(2, 14),
+Tuple.Create(2, 17),
+Tuple.Create(2, 19),
+Tuple.Create(2, 24),
+Tuple.Create(2, 26),
+Tuple.Create(2, 29),
+Tuple.Create(2, 31),
+Tuple.Create(2, 35),
+Tuple.Create(2, 37),
+Tuple.Create(2, 40),
+Tuple.Create(2, 42),
+Tuple.Create(2, 48),
+Tuple.Create(2, 50),
+Tuple.Create(2, 53),
+Tuple.Create(2, 55),
+Tuple.Create(2, 59),
+Tuple.Create(2, 61),
+Tuple.Create(2, 64),
+Tuple.Create(2, 66),
+Tuple.Create(2, 71),
+Tuple.Create(2, 73),
+Tuple.Create(2, 76),
+Tuple.Create(2, 78),
+Tuple.Create(2, 82),
+Tuple.Create(2, 84),
+Tuple.Create(2, 87),
+Tuple.Create(2, 89),
+Tuple.Create(3, 5),
+Tuple.Create(3, 7),
+Tuple.Create(3, 10),
+Tuple.Create(3, 13),
+Tuple.Create(3, 16),
+Tuple.Create(3, 18),
+Tuple.Create(3, 21),
+Tuple.Create(3, 25),
+Tuple.Create(3, 28),
+Tuple.Create(3, 30),
+Tuple.Create(3, 33),
+Tuple.Create(3, 36),
+Tuple.Create(3, 39),
+Tuple.Create(3, 41),
+Tuple.Create(3, 44),
+Tuple.Create(3, 49),
+Tuple.Create(3, 52),
+Tuple.Create(3, 54),
+Tuple.Create(3, 57),
+Tuple.Create(3, 60),
+Tuple.Create(3, 63),
+Tuple.Create(3, 65),
+Tuple.Create(3, 68),
+Tuple.Create(3, 72),
+Tuple.Create(3, 75),
+Tuple.Create(3, 77),
+Tuple.Create(3, 80),
+Tuple.Create(3, 83),
+Tuple.Create(3, 86),
+Tuple.Create(3, 88),
+Tuple.Create(3, 91),
+Tuple.Create(4, 5),
+Tuple.Create(4, 6),
+Tuple.Create(4, 10),
+Tuple.Create(4, 12),
+Tuple.Create(4, 16),
+Tuple.Create(4, 17),
+Tuple.Create(4, 21),
+Tuple.Create(4, 24),
+Tuple.Create(4, 28),
+Tuple.Create(4, 29),
+Tuple.Create(4, 33),
+Tuple.Create(4, 35),
+Tuple.Create(4, 39),
+Tuple.Create(4, 40),
+Tuple.Create(4, 44),
+Tuple.Create(4, 48),
+Tuple.Create(4, 52),
+Tuple.Create(4, 53),
+Tuple.Create(4, 57),
+Tuple.Create(4, 59),
+Tuple.Create(4, 63),
+Tuple.Create(4, 64),
+Tuple.Create(4, 68),
+Tuple.Create(4, 71),
+Tuple.Create(4, 75),
+Tuple.Create(4, 76),
+Tuple.Create(4, 80),
+Tuple.Create(4, 82),
+Tuple.Create(4, 86),
+Tuple.Create(4, 87),
+Tuple.Create(4, 91),
+Tuple.Create(5, 8),
+Tuple.Create(5, 9),
+Tuple.Create(5, 14),
+Tuple.Create(5, 15),
+Tuple.Create(5, 19),
+Tuple.Create(5, 20),
+Tuple.Create(5, 26),
+Tuple.Create(5, 27),
+Tuple.Create(5, 31),
+Tuple.Create(5, 32),
+Tuple.Create(5, 37),
+Tuple.Create(5, 38),
+Tuple.Create(5, 42),
+Tuple.Create(5, 43),
+Tuple.Create(5, 50),
+Tuple.Create(5, 51),
+Tuple.Create(5, 55),
+Tuple.Create(5, 56),
+Tuple.Create(5, 61),
+Tuple.Create(5, 62),
+Tuple.Create(5, 66),
+Tuple.Create(5, 67),
+Tuple.Create(5, 73),
+Tuple.Create(5, 74),
+Tuple.Create(5, 78),
+Tuple.Create(5, 79),
+Tuple.Create(5, 84),
+Tuple.Create(5, 85),
+Tuple.Create(5, 89),
+Tuple.Create(5, 90),
+Tuple.Create(6, 11),
+Tuple.Create(6, 13),
+Tuple.Create(6, 15),
+Tuple.Create(6, 22),
+Tuple.Create(6, 25),
+Tuple.Create(6, 27),
+Tuple.Create(6, 34),
+Tuple.Create(6, 36),
+Tuple.Create(6, 38),
+Tuple.Create(6, 45),
+Tuple.Create(6, 49),
+Tuple.Create(6, 51),
+Tuple.Create(6, 58),
+Tuple.Create(6, 60),
+Tuple.Create(6, 62),
+Tuple.Create(6, 69),
+Tuple.Create(6, 72),
+Tuple.Create(6, 74),
+Tuple.Create(6, 81),
+Tuple.Create(6, 83),
+Tuple.Create(6, 85),
+Tuple.Create(6, 92),
+Tuple.Create(7, 11),
+Tuple.Create(7, 12),
+Tuple.Create(7, 14),
+Tuple.Create(7, 22),
+Tuple.Create(7, 24),
+Tuple.Create(7, 26),
+Tuple.Create(7, 34),
+Tuple.Create(7, 35),
+Tuple.Create(7, 37),
+Tuple.Create(7, 45),
+Tuple.Create(7, 48),
+Tuple.Create(7, 50),
+Tuple.Create(7, 58),
+Tuple.Create(7, 59),
+Tuple.Create(7, 61),
+Tuple.Create(7, 69),
+Tuple.Create(7, 71),
+Tuple.Create(7, 73),
+Tuple.Create(7, 81),
+Tuple.Create(7, 82),
+Tuple.Create(7, 84),
+Tuple.Create(7, 92),
+Tuple.Create(8, 11),
+Tuple.Create(8, 13),
+Tuple.Create(8, 16),
+Tuple.Create(8, 22),
+Tuple.Create(8, 25),
+Tuple.Create(8, 28),
+Tuple.Create(8, 34),
+Tuple.Create(8, 36),
+Tuple.Create(8, 39),
+Tuple.Create(8, 45),
+Tuple.Create(8, 49),
+Tuple.Create(8, 52),
+Tuple.Create(8, 58),
+Tuple.Create(8, 60),
+Tuple.Create(8, 63),
+Tuple.Create(8, 69),
+Tuple.Create(8, 72),
+Tuple.Create(8, 75),
+Tuple.Create(8, 81),
+Tuple.Create(8, 83),
+Tuple.Create(8, 86),
+Tuple.Create(8, 92),
+Tuple.Create(9, 11),
+Tuple.Create(9, 12),
+Tuple.Create(9, 16),
+Tuple.Create(9, 22),
+Tuple.Create(9, 24),
+Tuple.Create(9, 28),
+Tuple.Create(9, 34),
+Tuple.Create(9, 35),
+Tuple.Create(9, 39),
+Tuple.Create(9, 45),
+Tuple.Create(9, 48),
+Tuple.Create(9, 52),
+Tuple.Create(9, 58),
+Tuple.Create(9, 59),
+Tuple.Create(9, 63),
+Tuple.Create(9, 69),
+Tuple.Create(9, 71),
+Tuple.Create(9, 75),
+Tuple.Create(9, 81),
+Tuple.Create(9, 82),
+Tuple.Create(9, 86),
+Tuple.Create(9, 92),
+Tuple.Create(10, 11),
+Tuple.Create(10, 14),
+Tuple.Create(10, 15),
+Tuple.Create(10, 22),
+Tuple.Create(10, 26),
+Tuple.Create(10, 27),
+Tuple.Create(10, 34),
+Tuple.Create(10, 37),
+Tuple.Create(10, 38),
+Tuple.Create(10, 45),
+Tuple.Create(10, 50),
+Tuple.Create(10, 51),
+Tuple.Create(10, 58),
+Tuple.Create(10, 61),
+Tuple.Create(10, 62),
+Tuple.Create(10, 69),
+Tuple.Create(10, 73),
+Tuple.Create(10, 74),
+Tuple.Create(10, 81),
+Tuple.Create(10, 84),
+Tuple.Create(10, 85),
+Tuple.Create(10, 92),
+Tuple.Create(11, 17),
+Tuple.Create(11, 18),
+Tuple.Create(11, 19),
+Tuple.Create(11, 20),
+Tuple.Create(11, 21),
+Tuple.Create(11, 29),
+Tuple.Create(11, 30),
+Tuple.Create(11, 31),
+Tuple.Create(11, 32),
+Tuple.Create(11, 33),
+Tuple.Create(11, 40),
+Tuple.Create(11, 41),
+Tuple.Create(11, 42),
+Tuple.Create(11, 43),
+Tuple.Create(11, 44),
+Tuple.Create(11, 53),
+Tuple.Create(11, 54),
+Tuple.Create(11, 55),
+Tuple.Create(11, 56),
+Tuple.Create(11, 57),
+Tuple.Create(11, 64),
+Tuple.Create(11, 65),
+Tuple.Create(11, 66),
+Tuple.Create(11, 67),
+Tuple.Create(11, 68),
+Tuple.Create(11, 76),
+Tuple.Create(11, 77),
+Tuple.Create(11, 78),
+Tuple.Create(11, 79),
+Tuple.Create(11, 80),
+Tuple.Create(11, 87),
+Tuple.Create(11, 88),
+Tuple.Create(11, 89),
+Tuple.Create(11, 90),
+Tuple.Create(11, 91),
+Tuple.Create(12, 23),
+Tuple.Create(12, 25),
+Tuple.Create(12, 27),
+Tuple.Create(12, 30),
+Tuple.Create(12, 32),
+Tuple.Create(12, 46),
+Tuple.Create(12, 49),
+Tuple.Create(12, 51),
+Tuple.Create(12, 54),
+Tuple.Create(12, 56),
+Tuple.Create(12, 70),
+Tuple.Create(12, 72),
+Tuple.Create(12, 74),
+Tuple.Create(12, 77),
+Tuple.Create(12, 79),
+Tuple.Create(12, 93),
+Tuple.Create(13, 23),
+Tuple.Create(13, 24),
+Tuple.Create(13, 26),
+Tuple.Create(13, 29),
+Tuple.Create(13, 31),
+Tuple.Create(13, 46),
+Tuple.Create(13, 48),
+Tuple.Create(13, 50),
+Tuple.Create(13, 53),
+Tuple.Create(13, 55),
+Tuple.Create(13, 70),
+Tuple.Create(13, 71),
+Tuple.Create(13, 73),
+Tuple.Create(13, 76),
+Tuple.Create(13, 78),
+Tuple.Create(13, 93),
+Tuple.Create(14, 23),
+Tuple.Create(14, 25),
+Tuple.Create(14, 28),
+Tuple.Create(14, 30),
+Tuple.Create(14, 33),
+Tuple.Create(14, 46),
+Tuple.Create(14, 49),
+Tuple.Create(14, 52),
+Tuple.Create(14, 54),
+Tuple.Create(14, 57),
+Tuple.Create(14, 70),
+Tuple.Create(14, 72),
+Tuple.Create(14, 75),
+Tuple.Create(14, 77),
+Tuple.Create(14, 80),
+Tuple.Create(14, 93),
+Tuple.Create(15, 23),
+Tuple.Create(15, 24),
+Tuple.Create(15, 28),
+Tuple.Create(15, 29),
+Tuple.Create(15, 33),
+Tuple.Create(15, 46),
+Tuple.Create(15, 48),
+Tuple.Create(15, 52),
+Tuple.Create(15, 53),
+Tuple.Create(15, 57),
+Tuple.Create(15, 70),
+Tuple.Create(15, 71),
+Tuple.Create(15, 75),
+Tuple.Create(15, 76),
+Tuple.Create(15, 80),
+Tuple.Create(15, 93),
+Tuple.Create(16, 23),
+Tuple.Create(16, 26),
+Tuple.Create(16, 27),
+Tuple.Create(16, 31),
+Tuple.Create(16, 32),
+Tuple.Create(16, 46),
+Tuple.Create(16, 50),
+Tuple.Create(16, 51),
+Tuple.Create(16, 55),
+Tuple.Create(16, 56),
+Tuple.Create(16, 70),
+Tuple.Create(16, 73),
+Tuple.Create(16, 74),
+Tuple.Create(16, 78),
+Tuple.Create(16, 79),
+Tuple.Create(16, 93),
+Tuple.Create(17, 23),
+Tuple.Create(17, 25),
+Tuple.Create(17, 27),
+Tuple.Create(17, 34),
+Tuple.Create(17, 46),
+Tuple.Create(17, 49),
+Tuple.Create(17, 51),
+Tuple.Create(17, 58),
+Tuple.Create(17, 70),
+Tuple.Create(17, 72),
+Tuple.Create(17, 74),
+Tuple.Create(17, 81),
+Tuple.Create(17, 93),
+Tuple.Create(18, 23),
+Tuple.Create(18, 24),
+Tuple.Create(18, 26),
+Tuple.Create(18, 34),
+Tuple.Create(18, 46),
+Tuple.Create(18, 48),
+Tuple.Create(18, 50),
+Tuple.Create(18, 58),
+Tuple.Create(18, 70),
+Tuple.Create(18, 71),
+Tuple.Create(18, 73),
+Tuple.Create(18, 81),
+Tuple.Create(18, 93),
+Tuple.Create(19, 23),
+Tuple.Create(19, 25),
+Tuple.Create(19, 28),
+Tuple.Create(19, 34),
+Tuple.Create(19, 46),
+Tuple.Create(19, 49),
+Tuple.Create(19, 52),
+Tuple.Create(19, 58),
+Tuple.Create(19, 70),
+Tuple.Create(19, 72),
+Tuple.Create(19, 75),
+Tuple.Create(19, 81),
+Tuple.Create(19, 93),
+Tuple.Create(20, 23),
+Tuple.Create(20, 24),
+Tuple.Create(20, 28),
+Tuple.Create(20, 34),
+Tuple.Create(20, 46),
+Tuple.Create(20, 48),
+Tuple.Create(20, 52),
+Tuple.Create(20, 58),
+Tuple.Create(20, 70),
+Tuple.Create(20, 71),
+Tuple.Create(20, 75),
+Tuple.Create(20, 81),
+Tuple.Create(20, 93),
+Tuple.Create(21, 23),
+Tuple.Create(21, 26),
+Tuple.Create(21, 27),
+Tuple.Create(21, 34),
+Tuple.Create(21, 46),
+Tuple.Create(21, 50),
+Tuple.Create(21, 51),
+Tuple.Create(21, 58),
+Tuple.Create(21, 70),
+Tuple.Create(21, 73),
+Tuple.Create(21, 74),
+Tuple.Create(21, 81),
+Tuple.Create(21, 93),
+Tuple.Create(22, 23),
+Tuple.Create(22, 29),
+Tuple.Create(22, 30),
+Tuple.Create(22, 31),
+Tuple.Create(22, 32),
+Tuple.Create(22, 33),
+Tuple.Create(22, 46),
+Tuple.Create(22, 53),
+Tuple.Create(22, 54),
+Tuple.Create(22, 55),
+Tuple.Create(22, 56),
+Tuple.Create(22, 57),
+Tuple.Create(22, 70),
+Tuple.Create(22, 76),
+Tuple.Create(22, 77),
+Tuple.Create(22, 78),
+Tuple.Create(22, 79),
+Tuple.Create(22, 80),
+Tuple.Create(22, 93),
+Tuple.Create(23, 35),
+Tuple.Create(23, 36),
+Tuple.Create(23, 37),
+Tuple.Create(23, 38),
+Tuple.Create(23, 39),
+Tuple.Create(23, 40),
+Tuple.Create(23, 41),
+Tuple.Create(23, 42),
+Tuple.Create(23, 43),
+Tuple.Create(23, 44),
+Tuple.Create(23, 45),
+Tuple.Create(23, 59),
+Tuple.Create(23, 60),
+Tuple.Create(23, 61),
+Tuple.Create(23, 62),
+Tuple.Create(23, 63),
+Tuple.Create(23, 64),
+Tuple.Create(23, 65),
+Tuple.Create(23, 66),
+Tuple.Create(23, 67),
+Tuple.Create(23, 68),
+Tuple.Create(23, 69),
+Tuple.Create(23, 82),
+Tuple.Create(23, 83),
+Tuple.Create(23, 84),
+Tuple.Create(23, 85),
+Tuple.Create(23, 86),
+Tuple.Create(23, 87),
+Tuple.Create(23, 88),
+Tuple.Create(23, 89),
+Tuple.Create(23, 90),
+Tuple.Create(23, 91),
+Tuple.Create(23, 92),
+Tuple.Create(24, 47),
+Tuple.Create(24, 49),
+Tuple.Create(24, 51),
+Tuple.Create(24, 54),
+Tuple.Create(24, 56),
+Tuple.Create(24, 60),
+Tuple.Create(24, 62),
+Tuple.Create(24, 65),
+Tuple.Create(24, 67),
+Tuple.Create(24, 94),
+Tuple.Create(25, 47),
+Tuple.Create(25, 48),
+Tuple.Create(25, 50),
+Tuple.Create(25, 53),
+Tuple.Create(25, 55),
+Tuple.Create(25, 59),
+Tuple.Create(25, 61),
+Tuple.Create(25, 64),
+Tuple.Create(25, 66),
+Tuple.Create(25, 94),
+Tuple.Create(26, 47),
+Tuple.Create(26, 49),
+Tuple.Create(26, 52),
+Tuple.Create(26, 54),
+Tuple.Create(26, 57),
+Tuple.Create(26, 60),
+Tuple.Create(26, 63),
+Tuple.Create(26, 65),
+Tuple.Create(26, 68),
+Tuple.Create(26, 94),
+Tuple.Create(27, 47),
+Tuple.Create(27, 48),
+Tuple.Create(27, 52),
+Tuple.Create(27, 53),
+Tuple.Create(27, 57),
+Tuple.Create(27, 59),
+Tuple.Create(27, 63),
+Tuple.Create(27, 64),
+Tuple.Create(27, 68),
+Tuple.Create(27, 94),
+Tuple.Create(28, 47),
+Tuple.Create(28, 50),
+Tuple.Create(28, 51),
+Tuple.Create(28, 55),
+Tuple.Create(28, 56),
+Tuple.Create(28, 61),
+Tuple.Create(28, 62),
+Tuple.Create(28, 66),
+Tuple.Create(28, 67),
+Tuple.Create(28, 94),
+Tuple.Create(29, 47),
+Tuple.Create(29, 49),
+Tuple.Create(29, 51),
+Tuple.Create(29, 58),
+Tuple.Create(29, 60),
+Tuple.Create(29, 62),
+Tuple.Create(29, 69),
+Tuple.Create(29, 94),
+Tuple.Create(30, 47),
+Tuple.Create(30, 48),
+Tuple.Create(30, 50),
+Tuple.Create(30, 58),
+Tuple.Create(30, 59),
+Tuple.Create(30, 61),
+Tuple.Create(30, 69),
+Tuple.Create(30, 94),
+Tuple.Create(31, 47),
+Tuple.Create(31, 49),
+Tuple.Create(31, 52),
+Tuple.Create(31, 58),
+Tuple.Create(31, 60),
+Tuple.Create(31, 63),
+Tuple.Create(31, 69),
+Tuple.Create(31, 94),
+Tuple.Create(32, 47),
+Tuple.Create(32, 48),
+Tuple.Create(32, 52),
+Tuple.Create(32, 58),
+Tuple.Create(32, 59),
+Tuple.Create(32, 63),
+Tuple.Create(32, 69),
+Tuple.Create(32, 94),
+Tuple.Create(33, 47),
+Tuple.Create(33, 50),
+Tuple.Create(33, 51),
+Tuple.Create(33, 58),
+Tuple.Create(33, 61),
+Tuple.Create(33, 62),
+Tuple.Create(33, 69),
+Tuple.Create(33, 94),
+Tuple.Create(34, 47),
+Tuple.Create(34, 53),
+Tuple.Create(34, 54),
+Tuple.Create(34, 55),
+Tuple.Create(34, 56),
+Tuple.Create(34, 57),
+Tuple.Create(34, 64),
+Tuple.Create(34, 65),
+Tuple.Create(34, 66),
+Tuple.Create(34, 67),
+Tuple.Create(34, 68),
+Tuple.Create(34, 94),
+Tuple.Create(35, 47),
+Tuple.Create(35, 49),
+Tuple.Create(35, 51),
+Tuple.Create(35, 54),
+Tuple.Create(35, 56),
+Tuple.Create(35, 70),
+Tuple.Create(35, 94),
+Tuple.Create(36, 47),
+Tuple.Create(36, 48),
+Tuple.Create(36, 50),
+Tuple.Create(36, 53),
+Tuple.Create(36, 55),
+Tuple.Create(36, 70),
+Tuple.Create(36, 94),
+Tuple.Create(37, 47),
+Tuple.Create(37, 49),
+Tuple.Create(37, 52),
+Tuple.Create(37, 54),
+Tuple.Create(37, 57),
+Tuple.Create(37, 70),
+Tuple.Create(37, 94),
+Tuple.Create(38, 47),
+Tuple.Create(38, 48),
+Tuple.Create(38, 52),
+Tuple.Create(38, 53),
+Tuple.Create(38, 57),
+Tuple.Create(38, 70),
+Tuple.Create(38, 94),
+Tuple.Create(39, 47),
+Tuple.Create(39, 50),
+Tuple.Create(39, 51),
+Tuple.Create(39, 55),
+Tuple.Create(39, 56),
+Tuple.Create(39, 70),
+Tuple.Create(39, 94),
+Tuple.Create(40, 47),
+Tuple.Create(40, 49),
+Tuple.Create(40, 51),
+Tuple.Create(40, 58),
+Tuple.Create(40, 70),
+Tuple.Create(40, 94),
+Tuple.Create(41, 47),
+Tuple.Create(41, 48),
+Tuple.Create(41, 50),
+Tuple.Create(41, 58),
+Tuple.Create(41, 70),
+Tuple.Create(41, 94),
+Tuple.Create(42, 47),
+Tuple.Create(42, 49),
+Tuple.Create(42, 52),
+Tuple.Create(42, 58),
+Tuple.Create(42, 70),
+Tuple.Create(42, 94),
+Tuple.Create(43, 47),
+Tuple.Create(43, 48),
+Tuple.Create(43, 52),
+Tuple.Create(43, 58),
+Tuple.Create(43, 70),
+Tuple.Create(43, 94),
+Tuple.Create(44, 47),
+Tuple.Create(44, 50),
+Tuple.Create(44, 51),
+Tuple.Create(44, 58),
+Tuple.Create(44, 70),
+Tuple.Create(44, 94),
+Tuple.Create(45, 47),
+Tuple.Create(45, 53),
+Tuple.Create(45, 54),
+Tuple.Create(45, 55),
+Tuple.Create(45, 56),
+Tuple.Create(45, 57),
+Tuple.Create(45, 70),
+Tuple.Create(45, 94),
+Tuple.Create(46, 47),
+Tuple.Create(46, 59),
+Tuple.Create(46, 60),
+Tuple.Create(46, 61),
+Tuple.Create(46, 62),
+Tuple.Create(46, 63),
+Tuple.Create(46, 64),
+Tuple.Create(46, 65),
+Tuple.Create(46, 66),
+Tuple.Create(46, 67),
+Tuple.Create(46, 68),
+Tuple.Create(46, 69),
+Tuple.Create(46, 94),
+Tuple.Create(47, 71),
+Tuple.Create(47, 72),
+Tuple.Create(47, 73),
+Tuple.Create(47, 74),
+Tuple.Create(47, 75),
+Tuple.Create(47, 76),
+Tuple.Create(47, 77),
+Tuple.Create(47, 78),
+Tuple.Create(47, 79),
+Tuple.Create(47, 80),
+Tuple.Create(47, 81),
+Tuple.Create(47, 82),
+Tuple.Create(47, 83),
+Tuple.Create(47, 84),
+Tuple.Create(47, 85),
+Tuple.Create(47, 86),
+Tuple.Create(47, 87),
+Tuple.Create(47, 88),
+Tuple.Create(47, 89),
+Tuple.Create(47, 90),
+Tuple.Create(47, 91),
+Tuple.Create(47, 92),
+Tuple.Create(47, 93),
+Tuple.Create(48, 95),
+Tuple.Create(49, 95),
+Tuple.Create(50, 95),
+Tuple.Create(51, 95),
+Tuple.Create(52, 95),
+Tuple.Create(53, 95),
+Tuple.Create(54, 95),
+Tuple.Create(55, 95),
+Tuple.Create(56, 95),
+Tuple.Create(57, 95),
+Tuple.Create(58, 95),
+Tuple.Create(59, 95),
+Tuple.Create(60, 95),
+Tuple.Create(61, 95),
+Tuple.Create(62, 95),
+Tuple.Create(63, 95),
+Tuple.Create(64, 95),
+Tuple.Create(65, 95),
+Tuple.Create(66, 95),
+Tuple.Create(67, 95),
+Tuple.Create(68, 95),
+Tuple.Create(69, 95),
+Tuple.Create(70, 95),
+Tuple.Create(71, 95),
+Tuple.Create(72, 95),
+Tuple.Create(73, 95),
+Tuple.Create(74, 95),
+Tuple.Create(75, 95),
+Tuple.Create(76, 95),
+Tuple.Create(77, 95),
+Tuple.Create(78, 95),
+Tuple.Create(79, 95),
+Tuple.Create(80, 95),
+Tuple.Create(81, 95),
+Tuple.Create(82, 95),
+Tuple.Create(83, 95),
+Tuple.Create(84, 95),
+Tuple.Create(85, 95),
+Tuple.Create(86, 95),
+Tuple.Create(87, 95),
+Tuple.Create(88, 95),
+Tuple.Create(89, 95),
+Tuple.Create(90, 95),
+Tuple.Create(91, 95),
+Tuple.Create(92, 95),
+Tuple.Create(93, 95),
+Tuple.Create(94, 95)
+    };
+    #endregion
   }
 }

branches/MemPRAlgorithm/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring/3.3/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring-3.3.csproj

@@ -58 +58 @@
   </ItemGroup>
   <ItemGroup>
+    <ProjectReference Include="..\..\HeuristicLab.Analysis\3.3\HeuristicLab.Analysis-3.3.csproj">
+      <Project>{887425B4-4348-49ED-A457-B7D2C26DDBF9}</Project>
+      <Name>HeuristicLab.Analysis-3.3</Name>
+      <Private>False</Private>
+    </ProjectReference>
     <ProjectReference Include="..\..\HeuristicLab.Collections\3.3\HeuristicLab.Collections-3.3.csproj">
       <Project>{958b43bc-cc5c-4fa2-8628-2b3b01d890b6}</Project>
@@ -91 +96 @@
       <Project>{23da7ff4-d5b8-41b6-aa96-f0561d24f3ee}</Project>
       <Name>HeuristicLab.Operators-3.3</Name>
+      <Private>False</Private>
+    </ProjectReference>
+    <ProjectReference Include="..\..\HeuristicLab.Optimization.Operators\3.3\HeuristicLab.Optimization.Operators-3.3.csproj">
+      <Project>{25087811-f74c-4128-bc86-8324271da13e}</Project>
+      <Name>HeuristicLab.Optimization.Operators-3.3</Name>
       <Private>False</Private>
     </ProjectReference>

branches/MemPRAlgorithm/HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring/3.3/Plugin.cs.frame

@@ -25 +25 @@
   [Plugin("HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring", "3.3.14.$WCREV$")]
   [PluginFile("HeuristicLab.Problems.GraphColoring-3.3.dll", PluginFileType.Assembly)]
+  [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Analysis", "3.3")]
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Collections", "3.3")]
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Common", "3.3")]
@@ -33 +34 @@
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Operators", "3.3")]
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Optimization", "3.3")]
+  [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Optimization.Operators", "3.3")]
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Parameters", "3.3")]
+  [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Problems.Instances", "3.3")]
   [PluginDependency("HeuristicLab.Persistence", "3.3")]
   public class HeuristicLabProblemsGraphColoringPlugin : PluginBase {