source: branches/OKBJavaConnector/ECJClient/src/ec/coevolve/README @ 10216

This package contains classes for doing certain kinds of coevolution:

  - 1-population competitive coevolution
  - 2-population parallel/parallel-previous competitive coevolution
  - N-population parallel/parallel-previous cooperative coevolution

ECJ does not presently support N-population sequential cooperative coevolution,
but there's no reason it couldn't -- it'd just need a special Breeder and one
or two minor tweaks to the MultiPopCoevolutionaryEvaluator.

"Parallel" methods are ones in which individuals are tested against other
individuals from the current generation.

"Sequential" methods are ones in which each subpopulation in turn is tested
against other individuals, then undergoes breeding, before other subpopulations
are tested against it.

"Parallel-previous" is the term we use to describe coevolutionary methods in
which individuals are tested against the *previous* generations' individuals
rather than the current ones.

Coevolution is largely defined by the form of evaluation, so this package
contains mostly Evaluators of different kinds.  The coevolution system places
each coevolved "population" in a separate ECJ subpopulation.  Fitness
assessment in coevolution typically consists of three parts:

  1. Preprocess the full population (all subpopulations) in some way
  2. Perform various tests on groups of individuals
  3. Postprocess the full population, which gathers all the test
     results and assesses fitness on the individuals.

These three elements are embodied in a Problem form called GroupedProblemForm,
which you are required to use.  It shouldn't be surprising to you that
your Problem subclass will need to understand what kind of coevolution it's
being involved in and assess fitness appropriately.  The GroupedProblemForm
class is:
  
  ec.coevolve.GroupedProblemForm

The evaluate(...) method in GroupedProblemForm is a bit unusual.  You are
given an array of individuals to test together -- the particular subpopulations
from which the individuals are drawn depends on the coevolution method.  The
subpopulations in question are also provided to you as an array.  You are also
provided with an array of booleans indicating WHICH individuals are supposed to
have their fitnesses updated each time.  Last, you're given a boolean telling
you whether fitnesses should be (temporarily) updated to reflect victories
won rather than actual scores (as in the case of Single Elimination Tournament).




1 POPULATION COMPETITIVE COEVOLUTION

Here members of a single subpopulation are tested against one another in some
fashion, often multiple times with multiple "testing partners", before their
fitness is assessed.  ECJ's implementation can be found in

  ec.coevolve.CompetitiveEvaluator

This evaluator has a number of ways that individuals can be tested.  First,
there is the issue of competition style:

  - Single Elimination Tournament.  Individuals are put into a
    single elimination tournament, and "winners" go on to compete
    further in the bracket.  It's common for single elimination
    tournament to be defined such that the degree to which an individual
    rises in the tournament is defined as his fitness.  You'll need
    to set a temporary fitness of individuals immediately during 
    evaluate(...), rather than waiting for Step 3 above, since this 
    "fitness" will determine which individual won a competition in the
    tournament.  Afterwards in postprocessing you can then set the final
    fitness of the individual.  Single Elimination Tournament requires
    that your subpopulation be a power of 2 in size.

  - Round Robin.  Every individual is tested exactly once against every
    other individual in the subpopulation.

  - K Random Opponents (One Way).  Each individual is tested against
    exactly K other individuals, chosen at random.

  - K Random Opponents (Two Ways).  Each individual is tested against
    AT LEAST K other individuals, chosen at random. Here the other
    individuals are expected to have their fitnesses updated as well.
    In some cases an individual may have one or two more tests than
    the others. 





2 POPULATION PARALLEL/PARALLEL-PREVIOUS COMPETITIVE COEVOLUTION

Here two subpopulations are pit against one another.  Members from one
subpopulation are tested against members of the other subpopulation.  ECJ's
implementation is found in

  ec.coevolve.MultiPopCoevolutionaryEvaluator

Each individual in a subpopulation will be tested against certain individuals
in the other subpopulation.  This class allows you to specify how many of three
kinds of individuals to test against:

  1. The fittest individuals in the other subpopulation from the
     previous generation
  
  2. Other individuals from the previous generation, selected via
     a selection method which you specify.

  3. Random individuals from the current generation

To implement 2-population methods, you'll need to set the number of
subpopulations to 2.  You are responsible for computing the fitness of
individuals in competitive form.




N POPULATION PARALLEL/PARALLEL-PREVIOUS COOPERATIVE COEVOLUTION 

Here N populations are tested in collaboration with one another.  Members from
one subpopulation are tested by grouping them with a member each from the other
subpopulations and assessing their joint fitness.  ECJ's implementation is
again

  ec.coevolve.MutltiPopCoevolutionaryEvaluator

See above for more information about how this class works.  To implement
n-population methods, you'll need to set the number of subpopulations to N
as appropriate.  You are responsible for computing the fitness of individuals
in some cooperative form.