Changes between Version 124 and Version 125 of ReviewHeuristicLab3.3.0Application


Ignore:
Timestamp:
04/08/10 22:02:08 (11 years ago)
Author:
swagner
Comment:

--

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • ReviewHeuristicLab3.3.0Application

    v124 v125  
    140140== Reviewer: vdorfer ==
    141141
    142 First of all: I would regard a user manual with first steps (shall I first create a new TSP or create a new SGA and how can they be combined...) as very important, for me at the first sight it was not really clear how to start.
    143  * swagner: A start page was added in r3202 which is shown when the optimizer is started. What do you think about it? Is it helpful when starting to work with HeuristicLab? Which additional information should be shown?
    144  * vdorfer: I like the start page, it gives a good first introduction. Maybe the second and the third example could run a bit longer...
    145 
    146142=== Priority: HIGH ===
    147  * It is possible to start an algorithm with a TSP without having loaded the TSPLib file --> leads to `IndexOutOfRangeException`
    148  * `PersistenceException` when saving a `TabuSearch` with a problem (no matter if TSP, Knapsack,..).
    149   * abeham: fixed in r3204
    150  * `PersistenceException` when saving an `EvolutionStrategy` (with and without a problem)
    151 
    152 === Priority: MEDIUM ===
    153  * In the results view I would show by default the quality data table (instead of first having to stop (pause) the algorithm, select the data table and resume the algorithm). When the tour visualization is done, this would be best to show by default.
     143 * It is possible to start an algorithm with a TSP without having loaded the TSPLib file --> leads to `IndexOutOfRangeException`.
     144 * `PersistenceException` when saving an `EvolutionStrategy` (with and without a problem).
     145
     146=== Priority: MEDIUM ===
     147 * In the results view I would show by default the quality data table (instead of first having to stop (pause) the algorithm, select the data table and resume the algorithm). When the tour visualization is done, this would be best to show by default.
     148   * swagner: Showing results by default is critical, as the continuous redraw of a result's value (e.g. quality chart, tour visualization) might consume a lot of runtime. Therefore the user should have to select a result manually, if he wants to look at a result.
    154149 * Add != Set Value; In all forms with a simple value (`IntData`, `DoubleData`, `BoolData`,..) a plus icon signalizes the possible change/edit. I would change the plus sign for example to a pencil (as you do not add a new value but change it).
    155  * A "Do you want to save your work" question is missing when clicking the "x" of an open SGA, TSP,...
     150 * A "Do you want to save your work" question is missing when clicking the "x" of an open SGA, TSP, ...
    156151 * A `TabuSearch` with a ch150 TSP is not running fluently, it jerks.
     152   * swagner: Which parameter settings of the tabu search were used? If an exhaustive move generator is used, the tabu search jerks as computing the whole set of possible moves is quite time-consuming.
    157153
    158154=== Priority: LOW ===
    159155 * The comments in the generated code of a `ProgrammableOperator` are German.
    160    * epitzer: this is a feature of the .NET runtime and depends on the installed operating system language
     156   * epitzer: This is a feature of the .NET runtime and depends on the installed operating system language.
    161157 
    162158----